Cars

Opinion: Should we let ‘market forces’ decide the fate of Canada’s auto industry? Not so fast

Opinion: Should we let ‘market forces’ decide the fate of Canada’s auto industry? Not so fast

Last week, one of the world’s largest carmakers announced that it would “halt all further investments” in the domestic auto industry. It said that the international situation, cheap imports and high local labour costs left it no option but to consider closing plants.

“We need to act now” said the company’s production head. “This has fundamentally changed our economic position.”

Stellantis in Brampton? No, Mercedes-Benz in Germany.

And not just Mercedes: Volkswagen, Europe’s largest car company, announced earlier this year that it will close factories and shed 100,000 workers. Germans have reason to fear that their car industry, until now an economic engine and export champion, is about to be hollowed out.

The global automobile industry is being buffeted

The global automobile industry is being buffeted by three major forces: China Shock 2.0, the rise of electric vehicles and Trump tariffs.

The last of these is the most important issue for Canada – at least in the short term. In the long run, however, the other two trends promise to bring deep changes. They are already delivering upheaval outside of North America.

Stellantis in default of funding agreement to retool Brampton plant, Joly notifies automaker

Some say that our auto industry deserves to disappear if it can’t hack it in the free market. But some of the most powerful forces weighing on the Canadian industry are not market forces. They’re functions of American protectionism, and Chinese industrial policy.

Back in the year 2000, Canada built nearly

Back in the year 2000, Canada built nearly three million vehicles. That was more than the People’s Republic of China. Last year, Canada produced fewer than half as many automobiles, while China turned out more than 34 million, making it by far the world’s largest carmaker.

China has invested so much in factories, and so quickly, that it has significant manufacturing overcapacity in many sectors, including cars. Chinese policy, subsidies and trade barriers enabled this outcome, and continue to encourage it. The result is a flood of cheap car exports.

And with China having so much excess manufacturing capacity, foreign car companies that invested in China and fostered its industry are under pressure, just like their Chinese competitors, to remain profitable by exporting cars and parts from China. Nearly all of China’s vehicle exports are now electric vehicles.

Just 11.8 per cent of new cars sold

Just 11.8 per cent of new cars sold in Canada this year were EVs. Market share is similar in the U.S. and South Korea, and even lower in Japan.

But EV sales are high and rising almost everywhere else. Between 2020 and 2025, EVs grew from 10 to 27 per cent of the market in the European Union. In Britain, they’re a third of the market. In China, 53 per cent.

EVs are a different technology than internal-combustion engine cars, with distinct manufacturing processes. And China has built the world’s leading EV manufacturing base.

Chinese automakers view their investments in Hungary as possible model for Canada

China Shock 1.0 hollowed out low-wage and basic

China Shock 1.0 hollowed out low-wage and basic industries in the developed world. China Shock 2.0 involves moving up the value chain into more advanced and complex manufactured products, such as cars.

Under then-president Joe Biden, the response was a 100-per-cent U.S. tariff on Chinese EVs, which Canada copied. President Donald Trump shredded that common front. Instead of protecting an integrated North American industry, he’s tried to disintegrate it.

Ottawa responded earlier this year by cutting our tariff on Chinese EVs to just 6.1 per cent, on up to 49,000 Chinese-made vehicles.

The developed world should have met China’s threat

The developed world should have met China’s threat to our manufacturing bases by sticking together. If we form an ex-China trading bloc, with low trade barriers between members and higher ones against Beijing, we have a shot at retaining our industrial capacity, while maintaining a competitive market, technological leadership and reasonable consumer prices.

At the very least, we need that within North America. But for it happen, Washington has to make a policy U-turn.

Speaking in Phnom Penh on Monday, Prime Minister Mark Carney said that his preference is for Canada’s auto industry to have “full opportunity in an integrated North American market.” But, as everyone knows, “that market has become less integrated because of U.S. trade actions.”

He said that if the Trump administration will

He said that if the Trump administration will not lower tariffs and allow a common North American industry, then Canada’s car plants and workers will have to look to “other options: European options; Asian options.”

Honda, Ford show commitment to Canadian auto plants despite tariffs

The best option for Canada’s auto industry is a return to the pre-Trump status quo of North American free trade. That common car market, the second largest in the world, would ideally be expanded by linking up with others, while maintaining barriers against China.

Mr. Trump’s spectacular midterm defeat could open the doorto a major change in U.S. trade policy, but today, Washington is the immediate threat to the Canadian auto industry. In response, Ottawa must continue to push back, and be patient.

The industry’s other challenges – the rise

The industry’s other challenges – the rise of China and the shift to a new vehicle technology – layer on top of that. Canada’s auto industry can only survive those threats if it regains the U.S. free-trade relationship, or replaces it.

If Mr. Carney’s auto industry strategy looks like he’s driving in two lanes at the same time, it’s because he is. He has no other choice.

He’s correctly signalled a clear preference for reopening the road south. But if it remains blocked, he will have to steer in new and unprecedented directions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *