Books

How Bookselling Saved My Writing Life

How Bookselling Saved My Writing Life

Lucy Tan on Working Alongside Other Readers and Freeing Herself of Universal Appeal

From 2017 to 2022 I was working on a book I loved, a quiet novel about three girls growing up in Wisconsin. The manuscript seemed promising at first. Its first chapter won me a fellowship back to the University of Wisconsin, where I had completed my MFA a year earlier, and whose generous faculty and staff supported me as I drafted my first novel. But when my agent and I submitted my second book to publishers in 2022, we didn’t get the response we were hoping for. Rather than continue to submit to a second round of editors, my agent suggested that I start another novel, something bigger and plottier and splashier,something more well-suited to the market we were in, a market that was becoming increasingly difficult for literary fiction.

Article continues after advertisement

I had spent five years on the novel, and my agent’s advice plunged me into a deep depression. On top of my sadness were layers of bitterness and spite. My largely unexamined assumptions about genre and where literary fiction fit in made “commercial” writing seem necessarily inauthentic. Still raw from rejection, I questioned what I was even doing. What was the point of writing fiction—especially literary fiction—in the first place?

I received each gift with the sincerity in which it was offered, and it was this generosity that reminded me of why I write in the first place. To connect with readers.

Literary fiction asks so much of a reader. Without genres and tropes to fall back on, a literary reader must be up for anything. To pick up a novel is to catapult yourself into the lives of others and exercise empathy without the guarantee of escapism. In fact, often a reader finds themselves staring right at the things they were trying to run from. It requires the kind of emotional bandwidth that is hard to demand of anyone nowadays, when real life can feel nearly dystopic. And speaking of such—what was I doing writing fiction when so much else needed doing in the world?

To be clear, I have never questioned the power of fiction, or the world’s need for it. Reading fiction makes people more empathetic, imaginative, and willing to engage with questions about what it means to be alive, not simply how to live a better life. My question had to do with me alone—what was Idoing writing fiction if there was no obvious need for myfiction? By the time I finally emerged out of lock-down, weak-kneed and gut-punched, I was at the lowest I had ever been.

That fall, I walked into my local independent bookstore and applied for a job. The decision to do so felt instinctual, almost atavistic, as though a primitive version of myself was leading me out of my sorrow and into safety. A writer friend once asked me if it hurt to work at a bookstore, to be surrounded by others’ publishing successes when my own project had fallen through. “Not at all,” I said. “Because it reminds me that I was a reader long before I ever was a writer. It reminds me what the point of it all is.”

Plus, working alongside other readers felt like coming home to family. On the schedule, I counted cash and straightened shelves. Off the schedule, I sometimes came into the bookstore and found a quiet corner in which to sit with a book. I started to have good days—ones where I could write again. On bad days, when I came in with a look of desperation, a coworker was always there to offer me the best of what they knew: the Patchett, the Baldwin, the Proust. This manga might do it; that poem was lovingly placed into my hands. I received each gift with the sincerity in which it was offered, and it was this generosity that reminded me of why I write in the first place. To connect with readers. To make a world for someone to disappear into when they don’t feel at home in their own.

From an author’s point of view, publishers all seem to be looking to acquire that one “big book” that everyone will want to read, and for months, this expectation had elicited in me an equally big wall of blankness. But as I watched my fellow booksellers excel at their jobs, I remembered that the goal is the opposite—not to sell the same book over and over again, but to find the right book for one person at a single point in time. To do that over and over again.

I firmly believe that writers can’t pull anything over the eyes of readers. If they’re phoning it in, it shows.

It might sound obvious, but this moment changed everything. Relieved of the pressure of universal appeal, my writing tentatively coalesced into a new project. I sent my draft to my agent in 75-page chunks, and each time I felt as vulnerable as I had been submitting my second book to publishers.

Slowly, Tiger’s Mouth emerged: a story about two young men who find in each other the one person who just might redeem his life. A story for those carrying the weight of complicated friendships and parental relationships, those striving for big dreams and feeling stretched thin along the way. The only way I kept myself going was that I promised myself if I finished this one, I would let myself quit. If I sold it, I could quit. If I didn’t sell it, I could also quit.

When I completed the draft last year, I had no idea if it was good. I had no means of judging anything at that point and nothing left in the reserves. I had turned myself inside out to make the book that may or may not have been my last. My agents (now I had two) were enthusiastic about my manuscript. After a few rounds of edits, they called it done. I said, “Let me look at it one more time.”

I trusted them when they said it was marketable, but only I could know if it was good. What if I had tried so hard to write by their standards that I had lost sight of mine? I firmly believe that writers can’t pull anything over the eyes of readers. If they’re phoning it in, it shows. If they assume to know too much about a character without looking at them closely enough, the character never comes alive. Thinking back to the torturous years it took to write Tiger’s Mouth, I couldn’t believe the book wouldn’t betray the darkness I’d felt when I’d written it, and that my anxieties and insecurities wouldn’t be staring me straight in the face once I read the first chapter.

Summer days in Seattle can stretch on for so long they seem interminable, and it was on one of these unrelenting afternoons that I sat down to read the book that had come to represent everything I hoped for and everything I feared. In the bright sunlight of my office, I couldn’t hide from anything. I started to read, and what I came away with surprised me. Yes, it was the story of my state of mind in the past few years, but not in the way I had thought. Tiger’s Mouth is a story of friendship and chosen family during a time when our world’s systems are so out of balance that they pose a threat to our lives. The darkness that I lived through—both regarding my own solipsism and our world’s very real threats—made its way onto the page, but it didn’t overwhelm the story. I had wanted so badly for my characters to find joy and redemption (for I, myself, wanted to find joy and redemption), that it had become a guiding principle of the book. This is how it read to me, anyway. Readers will have to decide for themselves.

This story begins with me alone, but it ends in community. On the day that Tiger’s Mouth sold, I was at the bookstore, speaking to my agents in the office while my coworkers eavesdropped from the floor. After I ended the call, I held my phone in my hand for a moment longer, savoring the mix of exhilaration and disbelief. When I walked out, teary-eyed, my coworkers’ joy amplified my own. There was nothing better than celebrating with those whose jobs had taught me to do mine better. Their cheers made me wonder whether anyone ever really writes alone. I had wanted success so badly, but what I had actually needed was sustenance: people who would fill me when I was empty, regular hours by which to measure my days, and a place to go that turned out to be so close to the place where I started from.

__________________________________

Tiger’s Mouth by Lucy Tan is available from Ballentine Books.

Ballentine BooksbooksellingcraftLucy TanPenguin Random HouseprocessTiger’s Mouthwriting

Lucy Tan

Lucy Tan grew up in New Jersey and has spent much of her adult life in New York and Shanghai. She received her B.A. from New York University and her M.F.A. from the University of Wisconsin-Madison, where she was awarded the 2016 August Derleth Prize. Her fiction has been published in journals such as Asia Literary Review and Ploughshares, where she was winner of the 2015 Emerging Writer’s Contest. What We Were Promised is her first novel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *