Fitness

Does science back its muscle, brain benefits?

Does science back its muscle, brain benefits?

In this first installment of Age Appropriate, Medical News Today’s Tim Snaith investigates whether creatine—the booming workout supplement—has legitimate, science-backed benefits for healthy aging

“Don’t die” is the slogan of the life extension movement that, for a small number of very wealthy people, involves dozens of daily supplements and many blood tests, not always with unqualified success. At the same time, AI is accelerating biological research, with models that can design new proteins, scan medical images, and find biological targets for aging treatments faster than labs can test them.

It makes this an exciting time to care about longevity. It also makes it confusing. Every week brings an exciting new molecule, a new mouse study, and a new headline promising extra decades.

Of all the supplements claimed to boost longevity, creatine has the most lab work behind it.

This week, we are launching a new series, Age Appropriate, to explore some of the hottest topics and hacks in healthy aging and longevity, taking a science-first, curiosity-driven approach to investigate whether these hacks align with the facts and highlight the promising vs. the premature.

In this first edition of Age Appropriate, we will look into creatine to see whether the research supports the longevity claims.

Let’s start with Medical News Today editor Tim Snaith’s experience with taking creatine supplements.

Q&A: My 10 years (on and off) with creatine

Yasemin Nicola Sakay: When did you start taking creatine?

Tim Snaith: I was surprised to find that I’ve been taking creatine, on and off, for a little over 10 years. My online order history shows a purchase way back in September 2016. I’ve lapsed several times, but I’ve been taking it pretty regularly since January this year.

Q: How much and how often do you take it?

A: I take 10 grams a day now, two scoops, stirred into cold water. Creatine doesn’t dissolve easily, so I keep a milk frother on standby to stir up the sediment and make sure I get the full dose. Stirring it into a hot drink might help, but I’ve been worried that the heat would affect the creatine.

Q: What pushed you to start taking creatine?

A: I started taking it around the same time I began taking resistance training seriously. I’d never been to the gym or lifted weights, and I understood that creatine could help me gain strength and maintain stamina.

More recently, I’ve become interested in its potential to postpone cognitive decline and increase my healthspan: the years when I live in relatively good health with a useful level of fitness. So I’ve increased my dose from one scoop (5 g) per day to two scoops (10 g) per day.

Q: Could any of these effects be placebo?

A: Yes, the no-nap effect could be a placebo. I’ve read that creatine may help with sleep, but I haven’t seen anything on reducing the need to nap. The increase in stamina when I’m walking, cycling, or training? I think that’s real.

Q:What’s one question you’d like to ask a researcher about creatine?

A: Is there a best way to take it? Can I mix it into milk, hot coffee, or tea? Are some versions better than others? This year, I switched to Creapure because I read that cheaper generic creatine monohydrate can have quality control issues — is it worth spending a little extra to ensure a better-quality product?

We reached out to Tracy Zaslow, MD, primary care sports medicine specialist at Cedars-Sinai Orthopedics and Sports Medicine in Los Angeles and a team physician for Angel City Football Club and LA Galaxy to answer Tim’s questions.

“Creatine monohydrate is generally available as a flavorless powder that can be mixed into water, juice, smoothies, or other beverages. There isn’t one beverage that is necessary to maximize its effectiveness. Mixing it into milk, coffee, or tea is generally fine, provided it is consumed promptly after mixing,” she told Medical News Today.

She also underscored the importance of choosing the right product, especially those that have undergone independent third-party testing through organizations such as NSF International or the U.S. Pharmacopeia.

“As with any supplement, quality matters because supplements are not regulated by the FDA in the same way as prescription medications,” she added.

The history of creatine

A French chemist first isolated creatine from meat in 1832 and named it after the Greek word for flesh, kreas. Then, a 1992 study from the Karolinska Institute in Sweden showed that taking creatine raises the amount stored in muscle. Athletes at that summer’s Barcelona Olympics started using it. U.S. sales of creatine had grown from $50 million a year in 1996 to more than $400 million by 2001. Creatine had become the powder in every gym bag.

Your body makes about half of the creatine it needs naturally from three amino acids, with the rest coming from meat and fish.

Creatine is mostly stored in muscle tissue as phosphocreatine, where it serves as a quick-release energy reserve. When you sprint or lift weights, phosphocreatine tops up ATP, your cells’ energy

But how does this apply to aging in the long term?

Creatine’s effects on aging muscles

After about age 30, we lose roughly 3% to 8% of our muscle mass every decade, which can lead to frailty, falls, and a loss of independence as we age.

Keeping muscle as you age is a practical way to extend your health span, but it takes work, and creatine appears to make more of the effort you put in.

Menopause: Research points to a role for creatine

Women store less creatine than men, and the hormone estrogen appears to affect how creatine is handled, making it a hot topic among researchers examining creatine’s effect in menopause. A 2025 review found promising signals across sleep, mood, muscle, and cognition, but the research remains limited.

Calling it “one of the more interesting and promising areas of creatine research,” Zaslow said it was encouraging to see that creatine may offer benefits beyond traditional athletic performance, especially “during perimenopause and menopause, [when] declining estrogen levels can contribute to losses in muscle mass, strength, and bone density.”

Zaslow noted that found that creatine may improve sleep consistency and brain oxygenation in perimenopausal women when combined with resistance training.

“However, [this study was] relatively small, and more research is needed to determine whether these findings translate into meaningful long-term benefits,” she said.

“[C]reatine deserves more attention as a potential tool for supporting women’s health during and after menopause. Maintaining muscle mass and strength is especially important as women age because it helps preserve mobility, balance, physical independence, and overall quality of life. Creatine, combined with regular resistance training and adequate nutrition, may help support those goals.”
— Tracy Zaslow, MD

The firmest evidence so far for creatine, however, has come from women who have passed menopause. A 2026 meta-analysis pooled data from 7 randomized trials involving 608 postmenopausal women with an average age of 62.

Creatine led to small but meaningful gains, about 0.37 kg more lean muscle and about 7.5 kg more on a leg press. However, those benefits only appeared when women took at least 5 grams (g) per day and engaged in resistance training. Doses of 3 g or less without training made no measurable difference.

Zaslow pointed out that despite modest improvements in lean muscle mass and strength, the researchers did not observe a meaningful increase in bone mineral density.

However, Zaslow also cautioned against viewing creatine as a treatment for menopause symptoms or osteoporosis.

“We need larger, longer-term clinical trials to better understand its effects on cognition, bone health, and other menopause-related changes. But the early evidence is encouraging,” she said.

How does creatine support the brain?

Research has shown promising results on how creatine may support brain health. In one small study, 15 young adults were kept awake for 21 hours. A single large dose (0.35 g per kg of body weight, roughly 25 g, or five times the typical dose for a 70 kg person) helped them maintain their memory and processing speed for several hours.

For everyday thinking, the picture is more mixed. A 2024 meta-analysis pooled 16 randomized trials involving 492 adults. It found:

  • a modest improvement in memory
  • faster reaction times on some tests
  • no clear effect on overall cognition, planning, and problem solving

However, people with health conditions, adults ages 18 to 60, and women saw clearer effects. Only 3 trials focused on people over age 60, but the benefits didn’t reach statistical significance in any of them, indicating that evidence on creatine’s benefits for aging brains remains limited.

The most recent positive signal, however, comes from Alzheimer’s research. In a at the University of Kansas, 20 people with the condition, ages 60 to 90, took 20 g a day for 8 weeks.

Their brain creatine rose by about 11%, and some cognitive scores improved. However, the study did not go far enough to establish causality, as there was no placebo group.

Creatine’s effect on overall longevity

A 2025 analysis of U.S. national survey data followed more than 4,000 adult humans for about 20 years. Those who got at least 1 gram of creatine a day from food were less likely to die of any cause.

However, this link weakened after accounting for age, smoking, and alcohol.

A follow-up study in adults over age 50 linked higher dietary creatine intake to lower mortality risk scores based on DNA methylation, a measure of biological aging.

What are the best ways to take creatine?

Creatine works by building up over weeks, not by giving you an instant power-up, so experts stress that consistency is key.

“Consistency is much more important than timing when taking creatine. Unlike caffeine or other supplements that may produce an immediate effect, creatine works by gradually increasing the amount stored in your muscles,” Zaslow said. “Taking it daily allows those stores to build up and remain elevated over time.”

MNT also previously spoke with Clarinda Hougen, MD, a primary care sports medicine specialist at Cedars-Sinai Orthopedics and Sports Medicine in Los Angeles, CA, on the topic of creatine.

“Creatine may be a useful tool as part of a broader strategy that includes resistance training, adequate protein intake, and regular physical activity,” Hougen said.

Here’s what research so far indicates about how to properly take creatine:

  • Timing barely matters. Taking it around a workout or with a meal containing carbs and protein may slightly improve uptake. But any time you remember to take it is the right time.
  • Stopping drains the tank. If you stop, your creatine stores will drift back to your baseline level over time.
  • Make it a habit. Work it into your daily routine, like your morning coffee.
  • Some people may benefit from taking more. Larger, very active people sometimes take 5-10 g per day. Some brain studies still use even higher doses.
  • Vegetarians and vegans tend to start with lower stores, so they often see bigger gains.

Zaslow concurred.

“There is no compelling evidence that taking creatine at a particular time of day produces significantly better results. Some people prefer taking it before or after exercise, while others find it easier to incorporate into their morning routine,” she said.

She also noted that a loading phase wasn’t necessary for most people and that taking it consistently, including on days when people aren’t exercising, was important.

“Some individuals may benefit more from creatine supplementation than others, particularly those who have lower baseline creatine levels. Vegetarians and vegans are good examples because creatine is found primarily in animal-based foods, such as meat, poultry, and fish,” said Zaslow. “People who follow plant-based diets tend to have lower creatine stores, so they may experience a greater response to supplementation.”

“For most healthy adults, a daily dose of 3–5 grams of creatine monohydrate is sufficient. Higher doses are sometimes used during a loading phase to saturate muscle stores more quickly, but this isn’t necessary for most people. The goal should be consistent supplementation at an appropriate dose rather than assuming that taking more will produce better results.”
— Tracy Zaslow, MD

On the topic of safety, for healthy people, creatine monohydrate has an excellent safety record across decades of trials.

“Creatine monohydrate is the most extensively studied form of creatine and is generally the best choice in terms of effectiveness, safety, and affordability. [It] is generally well tolerated by healthy adults,” Zaslow said.

However, creatine supplements can raise creatinine levels on blood tests, a common kidney marker, without harming the kidneys. So if you have kidney disease or are taking medications that affect your kidney function, talking with a doctor first is essential.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *