HisRoom.net Blog Men's Health Delphi Panel Agrees on Integrated Health Priorities for Justice-Involved
Men's Health

Delphi Panel Agrees on Integrated Health Priorities for Justice-Involved

Delphi Panel Agrees on Integrated Health Priorities for Justice-Involved

In a real-time modified Delphi consensus study, researchers and community partners reached expert agreement on seventy-six core components designed to guide a new integrated health intervention for justice-involved Black or African American men. The consensus panel evaluated clinical priorities spanning co-occurring mental health challenges, substance use disorders, and cardiovascular health risks. Published in the journal Health and Justice, the findings provide a structured framework for delivering coordinated medical and behavioral care to a population that experiences disproportionately severe rates of both carceral involvement and chronic cardiovascular illness.

The underlying research highlights significant public health disparities rooted in the intersection of carceral exposure and chronic physical illness. Criminal legal system involvement is strongly associated with compromised cardiovascular wellness, and cardiovascular disease currently represents the leading cause of death among incarcerated populations. Black or African American men bear a disproportionate burden of these adverse cardiovascular outcomes. Furthermore, the presence of co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders compounds vulnerability, substantially elevating long-term morbidity and mortality risks for individuals navigating the justice system.

Despite the documented urgency of addressing these overlapping vulnerabilities, existing clinical and social support models rarely provide combined treatment options. The investigators observed that few culturally tailored interventions currently integrate cardiovascular risk reduction directly with behavioral health services for co-occurring mental health and substance use disorders among justice-involved individuals. To overcome this limitation, the authors designed their study to synthesize existing empirical literature with direct, practical insights gathered from individuals possessing lived experience alongside professionals working across relevant carceral, medical, and community disciplines.

The research team employed a real-time modified Delphi

The research team employed a real-time modified Delphi methodology that engaged a diverse panel of twenty-five contributors. The expert panel comprised fourteen people with lived experience in the criminal legal system, co-occurring substance use, or mental health conditions, alongside eleven professionals specializing in carceral administration, behavioral health, and cardiovascular disease care. Drawing upon a focused literature review and preliminary stakeholder feedback, the investigators formulated one hundred and two distinct statements defining potential intervention priorities. Panel members reviewed and scored these items using standard Likert rating scales across sequential evaluation stages.

To ensure robust consensus, the study protocol specified that only statements attaining eighty percent or greater agreement among panelists would be formally retained. Following iterative ratings, participants achieved consensus on seventy-six of the one hundred and two proposed statements, representing an overall consensus rate of seventy-four point five percent. In addition to quantitative percent consensus measurements, the research team conducted thematic analyses of qualitative narrative responses to clarify specific participant perspectives and contextualize panel recommendations.

Panelists reached strong consensus regarding the intervention scope, endorsing a flexible, transdiagnostic structure tailored specifically for Black or African American men with any co-occurring substance use and mental health disorder. Furthermore, experts agreed that eligibility should encompass individuals with any degree of criminal legal system involvement rather than restricting participation to narrow legal categories. Regarding program delivery, the panel expressed a clear preference for in-person or hybrid treatment formats, explicitly favoring personal interaction over purely digital or remote service models.

When addressing chronic physical conditions, participants prioritized tackling

When addressing chronic physical conditions, participants prioritized tackling prominent cardiovascular disease risk factors through direct, internal program components rather than relying solely on external medical referrals. Panelists specifically selected smoking, hypertension, diabetes, and elevated cholesterol as essential targets requiring dedicated on-site management strategies. Throughout the evaluation, both lived-experience and professional contributors emphasized that cultivating interpersonal trust, maintaining operational flexibility, and adopting participatory co-creation principles represent critical operational pillars necessary to sustain meaningful participant engagement and long-term therapeutic impact.

The study authors concluded that these consensus findings establish foundational guidance for creating culturally responsive, integrated interventions that concurrently target cardiovascular disease and co-occurring behavioral conditions. By defining core design elements supported by both community members and clinicians, the resulting framework provides actionable evidence to inform broader public health initiatives aimed at diminishing health disparities. The investigators noted that these insights can directly assist ongoing reform efforts across carceral facilities, community behavioral health providers, and public health systems.

Subject of Research: Integrated mental health, substance use, and cardiovascular care intervention design for justice-involved Black men

Article Title: Heart, soul, and recovery: a real-time

Article Title: Heart, soul, and recovery: a real-time modified Delphi study on an integrated mental health, substance use and cardiovascular care intervention for justice-involved Black/African American men

Article References: Gaba, A., Nick, G. A., Fagan, S. N., Ojo, W., & McManus, D. D. (2026). Heart, soul, and recovery: a real-time modified Delphi study on an integrated mental health, substance use and cardiovascular care intervention for justice-involved Black/African American men. Health & Justice. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40352-026-00455-8

DOI:10.1186/s40352-026-00455-8

Keywords: Delphi study, cardiovascular disease, mental health, substance use disorders, criminal legal system, Black men’s health, health disparities, cultural tailoring, integrated care, hypertension, diabetes, smoking cessation, high cholesterol, lived experience, transdiagnostic intervention, public health

News. Delphi Panel Agrees on Integrated Health Priorities for Justice-Involved Black Men. Scienmag

Exit mobile version