HisRoom.net Blog Fitness Club 24 gets $300,000 Urban Renewal grant in 4-3 vote; majority not persuaded by winner-loser argument — Columbia Community Connection News Mid
Fitness

Club 24 gets $300,000 Urban Renewal grant in 4-3 vote; majority not persuaded by winner-loser argument — Columbia Community Connection News Mid

Club 24 gets $300,000 Urban Renewal grant in 4-3 vote; majority not persuaded by winner-loser argument — Columbia Community Connection News Mid

Club 24 gets $300,000 Urban Renewal grant in 4-3 vote; majority not persuaded by winner-loser argument

Club 24 is expected to open in the Spring of 2027 in the former Discounts Plus building in downtown The Dalles. Owner OJ Fian
Club 24 is expected to open in the Spring of 2027 in the former Discounts Plus building in downtown The Dalles. Owner OJ Fiandor said he would be opening the club regardless of whether his application for $300,000 in urban renewal money was approved.

The Dalles, Ore., Nov. 18, 2026 — Columbia Gateway Urban Renewal Agency members approved an incentive grant of up to $300,000 Tuesday for Club 24 to make improvements to the former Discounts Plus building at 212 E. Second St., despite concerns that the new gym could hurt established fitness businesses.

Orien “OJ” Fiander from his Facebook post announcing the new gym in The Dalles.

The decision came after Club 24 owner OJ Fiandor told the board the business would open in The Dalles with or without the grant. The funding would allow the company to complete some improvements sooner rather than spreading the work over five to 10 years.

“No matter what, we’re moving ahead,” Fiandor said responding to a question from Board Chair Dan Richardson.

The board’s debate centered on a question that surfaced repeatedly during public testimony and board discussion: When Urban Renewal awards money to improve a private property, is it helping downtown or picking winners and losers among competing businesses?

The vote on Tuesday, showed that a majority of the board were not persuaded by the claims of unfair advantage.

Board members acknowledged the potential impact on existing gyms. Kristin Lillvik described the decision as “the most difficult they had faced” since joining the board.

But a majority concluded that the agency’s responsibility was to evaluate the application against its mission and invest in improvements to a downtown building that needs substantial infrastructure work — not to decide which fitness businesses should succeed.

Jill Amery

The vote was 3-3 before Jill Amery cast the deciding vote in favor. Bets Stelzer, Kristin Lillvik and Walter Denstedt supported the grant. Chair Dan Richardson, Marcus Swift and Timothy “Mac” McGlothlin voted against it.

Amery, who is also the Wasco County Tax Assessor, said she understood the concerns as both a community member and a member of a local gym. She also said her work with property valuations had shown her how Urban Renewal investments can increase property values and generate additional tax revenue for local taxing districts.

“I’m so sorry that other businesses may be harmed, but we’re investing in the infrastructure, not business,” Amery said.

Stelzer also rejected the idea that approving the grant meant the agency was choosing one gym over another. She said Club 24 was moving ahead regardless of the grant, and the board’s decision was about whether the project met Urban Renewal’s established criteria.

“If we ignored what we’re here to do and tried to help ease the suffering of local gym owners by this decision, that would be picking winners and losers,” Stelzer said.

The grant is intended for eligible building improvements, not gym equipment. Staff said the work includes items such as electrical and plumbing upgrades, windows, HVAC and asbestos removal. Those improvements, they argued, would remain valuable to the property even if Club 24 eventually left.

The building has long needed significant work, economic development officer Jacob Anderson told the board. He also noted that HeroGym, operated by Jeremy Garner across the street, is in a building owned by Todd Carpenter that previously received Urban Renewal improvements. Anderson said that property had already benefited from the program’s investment.

That point added another dimension to the debate over whether the grant represented unequal treatment of local businesses.

Existing gyms warn of impact

Owners and employees of existing fitness businesses told the board they feared Club 24 could draw enough customers away to threaten smaller operations.

Gretchen Sharp

Gretchen Sharp, manager of The Dalles Athletic Club, said local gyms had worked to establish their own niches and were trying to make the market work for everyone. Timothy Dolly, co-owner of the club, said improving downtown should not come at the expense of businesses on its edges.

Renee McClung, who works at Iron Fitness and previously worked at The Dalles Athletic Club, questioned whether the local market could support another large gym. She said established clubs were struggling to maintain 500 to 600 members while Club 24’s projections called for 800 members in its first year.

Sam Perez, owner of Iron Horse Gym

Chad Chieza, a HeroGym customer, said he welcomed competition but objected to using public money to give one competitor a financial advantage.

“My objection is to the government giving one competitor a substantial financial advantage by providing them the maximum award possible under this grant program,” he said.

HeroGym’s owner, Jeremy Garner, had invested his own money to build the business, board members noted. Richardson said Garner had told him the arrival of Club 24 had already contributed to a drop in memberships and that he feared his business could close after the new gym opened.

Fiandor says Club 24 will move ahead

Fiandor said he grew up in Glenwood, Washington, has family in the area and often came to The Dalles while growing up. He said he had spent about 10 years looking for the right location and was excited to make Club 24 in The Dalles a flagship for his business.

He described the building’s east-facing exterior as an eyesore and said he wanted to improve its appearance as part of making the property an asset to downtown.

Fiandor also pushed back on the suggestion that an established gym operator would be unable to compete in a market with existing businesses. He said he has been in the fitness business since about 2000 and has had to repeatedly change his business model as competitors entered the markets where he operates.

“When you’re in business as long as I have, all of a sudden you recreate yourself,” he said. “I’m like on version 20 or 30 at this point.”

He cited Planet Fitness, which he said offers memberships for about $15 a month, as an example of the low-cost competition some of his other facilities face, noting the competitor is making inroads into smaller communities. He said competition has forced him to adapt over the years.

More on the Market

Fiandor said the fitness industry has seen a substantial increase in membership over the past three to four years, with adults ages 25 to 34 now driving much of the growth. He said that age group is Club 24’s primary target market and one he believes is underserved in The Dalles. He also cited a national average of 22% participation in gym memberships, saying that applying that rate to the local population within a typical 15-minute drive could indicate room for another fitness business.

That is approximately 3,700 people based on a population number of 17,000.

Fiandor said Club 24’s mix of free weights, cardio equipment and longevity amenities such as sauna and cold plunge is designed to appeal to younger members while also offering services for older customers.

Fiandor also clarified that Club 24 would not offer yoga. He said the business focuses on fitness and sees yoga studios as complementary rather than direct competitors.

Fiandor said Club 24 would employ at least one full-time worker, with the remaining positions part time. He said the company’s membership patterns should keep parking from becoming a problem: About 50% of members typically work out before 8 a.m., and another 40% use the gym between 4 and 8 p.m. A board member cited the application’s estimate of 32 parking spaces and asked whether the lot could accommodate a projected membership of up to 800. Fiandor said the usage patterns would spread demand across those periods and make parking manageable.

The agency’s approval does not guarantee Club 24 will receive the full $300,000. The grant is capped at that amount and applies to eligible improvements under the agency’s program requirements.

The DallesUrban RenewalClub 24$300k grant awardedSplit voteNov. 182026

Exit mobile version