HisRoom.net Blog Podcasts ‘Seriously revolting’: The best and worst Christmas sandwiches
Podcasts

‘Seriously revolting’: The best and worst Christmas sandwiches

‘Seriously revolting’: The best and worst Christmas sandwiches

Nothing beats a sandwich – especially a Christmas sandwich made with leftovers from the feast – assembled with care at home. The flavours take on a renewed vigour between the bread. But when you’re on the move or stuck in the office, the supermarkets’ extensive range of festive rounds can be a handy fix. 

Every retailer seeks to cram the turkey and trimmings into a transportable lunch; some throw in Brussels sprouts and red cabbage for good measure. But this year certain producers have created such ghastly offerings that there’s a lesson we would all do well to heed: just because you can put something between two slices of bread, doesn’t mean you should.

Rankings: at a glance

How I tasted

Someone else removed the sandwiches and wraps from packaging and placed them on plates marked with letters, to anonymise them. I interrogated the fillings and tasted individual components separately as well as together with the bread. When the prices were revealed, I gave a judgement score.

The best traditional Christmas sandwiches

Best Buy traditional Christmas sandwich

Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Shredded Turkey & Baconaise Wrap

Where to buy

The mixture of ingredients (namely the “bacon flavour seasoning paste”) doesn’t sound like something I’d want to put in my mouth, but the extraordinary thing is it works. While I can’t discern the individual ingredients (roasted pickled Savoy cabbage and Brussels sprouts are purportedly in there, along with butter-basted turkey, stuffing, bacon and lettuce), there’s an enjoyable freshness to this.

Best Value Traditional Christmas Sandwich

Lidl Turkey Feast Sandwich

Where to buy

For a plain-looking sandwich this has a remarkably rich, authentic-tasting stuffing which mysteriously transports me to the middle of Christmas Day. The sandwich looks well constructed, put together by someone who cares.

Aldi Turkey Feast Sandwich

Where to buy

These strike me as very good quality ingredients; the turkey is soft and unusually full of flavour (well-seasoned), and I like the tartness of the cranberry sauce. The bacon looks like proper pancetta. A good one, this one.

Co-op Turkey Feast Sandwich

Where to buy

You can taste all the component parts without it turning into a congealed mess, which can happen in a sandwich. These seem like well-made, quality ingredients. There’s a good amount of turkey, stuffing and bacon.

Tesco Turkey & Trimmings Sandwich

Where to buy

This tastes like something a student with the munchies has concocted at 4am, but I really like it – perhaps it’s nostalgia talking. The sausage is well seasoned, the stuffing has good flavour and there’s a generous amount of turkey between the bread.

I also tasted

Asda Classic Festive Feast Sandwich

Take a bite and there’s no hint of holly, no ivy, no Santa, no sleigh bells – there’s nothing festive about this. The stuffing is indeterminate protein, a soggy paste that doesn’t taste like stuffing. The rest of the meat is not much better.
Buy at Asda £3.00

M&S Food Turkey Feast Sandwich

The point of stuffing is to add a wonderful seasoning to a dish, but the stuffing in this is mean and underwhelming. A sad offering; a sandwich dashed off by someone who doesn’t care – like a mother-in-law who can’t wait to get rid of you.
Buy at M&S £5.10

Waitrose Turkey, Stuffing & Bacon Sandwich

This tastes like the discarded leftovers from a Christmas lunch two weeks ago. A very measly amount of turkey (barely half a piece slice), with a very mean degree of stuffing.
Buy at Waitrose £4.60

Best Christmas sandwiches with a twist

Best Buy Christmas sandwich with a twist

Lidl Deluxe Festive Yorkshire Pudding Wrap

Where to buy

What a monstrous thing! The whole point of a Yorkshire pudding is that it’s meant to be fluffy; once you roll it out and turn it into a wrap you discredit the whole idea. So this is an outrageous concoction, but as something quirky for Christmas (with dipping gravy!), I’ll admit it’s fun. You have to heat it, and that yields a rich sauce and well-seasoned sausage. But, my word, it’s messy; I wouldn’t want to sit anywhere near someone eating this.

Best Value Christmas sandwich with a twist

Aldi Specially Selected Wiltshire Gammon and Christmas Slaw Bloomer

Where to buy

This stands out because it looks more homemade than the others on test. The component parts are really good: the meat really tastes like gammon, the spiced vegetables deliver the vinegar tang of a homemade condiment; there’s a generous spoonful of mayonnaise. I don’t get the advertised hot honey flavour in the mayo, but it works well enough.

Where to buy

This is so wrong in concept, so hideous in composition – and the most disturbing thing of all is that I really like it. It’s like apple crumble on drugs.

Co-op Irresistible Posh Prawn Cocktail Sandwich

Where to buy

A wholly decent prawn sandwich, in which the lettuce manages to hold its own. But for a fully-fledged, proper prawn cocktail, it’s too light on the paprika.

Morrisons The Best Boxing Day Chicken Curry Wrap

Where to buy

Producers putting chicken in their festive sandwich, this is a massive missed opportunity. It’s the one time of the year you don’t eat chicken. That being said, this is a very pleasant cold chicken curry, lifted by some freshness and crunch from some onion. Flavour-wise, it really works.

I also tasted

M&S 12 Days of Christmas Wrap

I can see turkey, stuffing, carrot, cabbage, rocket and cheese in here, and while I admire the ambition there’s far too much going on. Much like when you over-decorate the Christmas tree and, before you know it, the whole thing has collapsed in a heap.
Buy at M&S £5.50

Morrisons Festive Bhaji Sandwich

The bhaji mixture is delicious but doesn’t suit the assembly, which proves the rule that not everything can be turned into a sandwich. The beetroot bleeds into the bread and makes it look unappetising.
Buy at Morrisons £3.40

Waitrose Korean Style Chicken Wrap

A nice autumnal flavour, but the “gochujang-style cranberry sauce” is lacking any spice. Hard to call this festive; it might just as well be February 12th.
Buy at Waitrose £4.15

Lidl Brie & Cranberry Sandwich

The miserly swipe of cranberry sauce provides the barest hint of Christmas, and the sandwich proves why no one should put brie in a sandwich – if you can slice it this thinly, the texture is all wrong. A two-fingered salute to the French fromage.
Buy at Lidl £2.99

Tesco Pigs in Blankets Sandwich

This is not pigs in blankets, this is just sausage and bacon. And the mayonnaise is seriously revolting. In fact, it’s one of the most revolting sandwiches I’ve eaten.
Buy at Tesco £3.25

Asda All The Trimmings Wrap

No hint of flavour of any kind in this vegan wrap; there’s just texture of wrap and the subtlest suggestion of crunch from a lettuce leaf. It’s like opening a present and discovering nothing inside.
Buy at Asda £3.00

Telegraph readers have their say

We invited 36 Telegraph readers to take part in their own blind taste test – would they agree with William Sitwell about the best (and worst) Christmas sandwiches? At The Clermont Hotel in London Victoria, our guests gamely tucked into this year’s supermarket ranges, and they didn’t hold back in their assessments of the products for flavour, texture and overall festive cheer.

UPFs explained

If you are concerned about ultra-processed foods, The Telegraph wants to provide enough detail to inform your shopping choices, hence why we flag “markers of ultra-processing” (MUPs) in the ingredient lists of products on test.

MUPs are ingredients that are used in industrial food production but not generally by home cooks, and they include preservatives, palm oil, colouring, flavouring, acidity regulators, alternative sugars like dextrose, and emulsifiers.

Below, we have set out how many MUPs can be found in each product. It’s an approximation, as there’s no definitive list: some ingredients are not reckoned MUPs by every expert, while others are considered to be MUPs only in certain circumstances.

Exit mobile version