Bombs, floods and disaster in this week’s literary fiction: A VERY COLD WINTER by Fausta Cialente, ADDER STONE by Clare Clark, LESSONS IN HARMONY by Jonathan Coe
A Very Cold Winter is available now from the Mail Bookshop
A VERY COLD WINTER by Fausta Cialente (Scribner £10.99, 288pp)
Originally published in 1966, this is the first of the Italian feminist writer Cialente’s novels to appear in English.
It’s a treat. The year is 1946, and as a bitter Milanese winter gets under way, a woman named Camilla has gathered her extended family in a cramped attic that has survived amidst the city’s ruins.
Nothing is as it was before the war, yet life carries on: among the attic’s inhabitants, dreams are harboured, attraction kindled, and momentous decisions weighed.
And as Camilla’s three children strive perilously toward the future, Camilla herself is drawn back: to the country home where her ageing mother still lives, and where a would-be suitor promises security.
Throughout, Cialente moves fluidly and with great empathy between perspectives, bringing the characters that populate this memorable intergenerational portrait brimmingly alive.
Adder Stone is available now from the Mail Bookshop
ADDER STONE by Clare Clark (Wilton Square Books £17.99, 320pp)
How can we learn from the past if we don’t even know what happened?
This is the question that Clark poses in her author’s note, and her novel more broadly, which focuses on the drive for Welsh nationalism following the 1963 drowning of a Welsh valley to supply water to Liverpool.
Spinning out from actual events, we follow a family displaced by the reservoir: Olwen, who chafes against the constraints of the farming life; her husband, Dai, who is as wedded to the land as Olwen is eager to fly; and their teenage son Emyr, who sees in the IRA a template for a Welsh army against English imperialism, with predictably grave consequences.
Clark has some terrific turns of phrase in this evocative, increasingly tense novel of freedom and the fierceness of a mother’s love.
Lessons in Harmony is available now from the Mail Bookshop
LESSONS IN HARMONY by Jonathan Coe (Viking £20, 272pp)
This novel, about the friendship between the French composer Maurice Ravel and the English composer Ralph Vaughan Williams, is a somewhat odd affair.
It’s framed as a memoir by the man who introduced them, a (fictional) music critic by the name of P. V. Mylonas, although this is in some part Mylonas’s story, too, especially once the two main characters are separated (and irrevocably changed) by the disaster of the First World War.
There’s plenty of fun to be had – a slapstick set-piece involving a piano; RVW’s indifference to French cuisine contrasted to Ravel’s enthusiasm for steak-and-oyster pie – together with the serious reflections you’d expect on national identity.
But for those who don’t share the author’s avowed passion for his subjects, the shifts of tone and focus don’t add up to an altogether persuasive outing.

