Books

Authors File Complaint Against Alabama Public Library Service

Authors File Complaint Against Alabama Public Library Service

With representation from the legal organization Democracy Forward, three authors and their allies have filed a federal complaint to challenge Alabama’s administrative policy on material deemed “inappropriate for children.” The case will be heard in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama’s northern division.

In November 2025, Alabama Public Library Service (APLS) board revised administrative code 520-2-2-.03 to prohibit “any materials regarding transgender procedures, gender ideology, or the concept of more than two biological genders.” Since then, public libraries in the state have not been allowed to acquire youth materials that are perceived to have violated the regulation, and any such materials already in collections must be reshelved in adult sections. Any public library that acquires such material or fails to move existing material “becomes ineligible for further state funding,” Democracy Forward noted in a press statement.

Plaintiffs in Rosewaterv.the Executive Board of the Alabama Public Library Service, including the anti-censorship group Read Freely Alabama, say the new amendment discriminates against people with LGBTQ+ identities and has resulted in the author-plaintiffs’ 2026 books being rejected for purchase by the Gadsden (Ala.) Public Library. Parent and youth plaintiffs were denied their requests that the library order three books with transgender characters: Buried Feelings, by Kit Rosewater; But I Hate Him, by Page Powars; and The Hidden Continent, by Phoenix McDonald.

The October 30 complaint asserts that the amendment

The October 30 complaint asserts that the amendment is discriminatory and overbroad, in violation of the First Amendment, and vague, in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment’s due process clause. No definition of “gender ideology” or “transgender procedures” is provided in the regulation.

In addition, plaintiffs argue that the rule influences authors’ ability to pursue creative work. Each author “has suffered and is suffering financial injury,” according to the filing.

Named defendants include the seven members of the Alabama Public Library Services board, in their professional capacities, including chairman John Wahl, who until March was also the chair of the Alabama Republican Party.

‘Normalized Representation’

Rosewater, who is the regional lead of New

Rosewater, who is the regional lead of New Mexico Authors Against Book Bans and the chair of the Freedom to Read New Mexico coalition, told PW that the case “intersected with my role as an author and my particular title,” a novel told from the first-person point-of-view of a cis-female whose love interest is transgender. She decided to join as a plaintiff, she said, because “I’m within the queer community, and it was really important for me to use the privileges and the experience that I have to advocate for all of my queer siblings under that umbrella.”

“I want kids to be able to grow up seeing this normalized representation, positive representation, celebrated representation on the shelves,” Rosewater added.

Powars, who is a transgender man, seconded Rosewater’s perspective. “I feel like a lot of people believe this is solely about kids who identify as transgender, but it’s about all teenagers’ ability to accept one another,” he said. “I come at it with an angle of trying to help cis people see trans people better.”

He also got involved as an author-plaintiff because

He also got involved as an author-plaintiff because “the entire public library system is being held hostage for funding,” he said. “I rely on brick-and-mortar bookstores, but teens need more options,” namely free lending from circulating library collections.

For McDonald, a self-published, transgender author without the backing of a Big Five publisher, The Hidden Continent is the third book in a queer-normative trilogy and a labor of love. “I wrote these books as representations of queer people, trans people, disabled people, and it made me angry to have legislators step forward and say, ‘we’re not going to allow you access to read it,’” McDonald said.

He noted that “of course these lawsuits get filed all the time as constitutional rights violations, but they’re also violating my rights as an author in a capitalist society: they’re not going to allow libraries to buy my book.”

Co-plaintiff Rosewater agreed

Co-plaintiff Rosewater agreed. “When you have restrictions like this come into play, it creates a chill factor across the state and over state lines as well,” she said. “For so many of us, the only way we can cobble together a livelihood is to sell books and then do author visits, author programming, and book clubs,” including virtual visits. “When educators and librarians are nervous about potential controversy, because they see what’s happening nationally, it takes all the opportunities away.”

The complaint comes after months of attacks to Alabama’s public libraries and amid threats to library budgets that are tied to youth materials. In March 2025, APLS froze state funding for the Fairhope (Ala.) Public Library, which had refused to move books from the teen to the adult section; titles in question included Susan Kuklin’s Beyond Magenta: Transgender Teens Speak Out, Patricia McCormick’s Sold, and Lauren Myracle’s Shine. In January, APLS voted to strip Fairhope’s funding altogether, and in June, APLS instructed all public libraries to submit their collection policies for compliance review in order to remain eligible for 2027 funding.

Dan Novack, Penguin Random House general counsel, spoke with PW because Rosewater’s novel is published by Delacorte Romance; PRH is not a party to this case. To him, the Alabama situation illustrates the evolution of book banning.

It started with the anti-CRT [critical race theory]

“It started with the anti-CRT [critical race theory] on college campuses, and that morphed into anti-DEI and things like that,” Novack said. “It was African American stories that first came under fire, and as we’re catching our breath, it took a hard turn and became mostly about LGBT stories,” because sex and sexuality tend to be “part and parcel of a story about a person coming into their identity.” In books including Rosewater’s, in which the characters are not physically intimate with each other, “we’re back to viewpoint discrimination, not content.”

That’s why book banners come after libraries as well, Novack said. “The library space is not only a sales channel for authors,” he observed. “Especially for youth titles, librarians are often the strongest kind of influencers [and] economic intermediaries. By buying the book and selling it right, they help the retail channel; school visits, library visits, all those things are critically important” to the book ecosystem and diverse representation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *