I currently own a gas-powered 2017 Ram 1500 Longhorn Laramie that I bought new before the prices went crazy. At the time, I needed the truck for towing a 28-foot house trailer across the continent and back, but now I own a cottage and no longer tow much more than the odd U-Haul moving trailer. I also carry stuff like bulk mulch and soil from garden centres to my home and cottage, so I do still like the versatility of a truck.
I’m a fan of electric vehicles and have Level 2 chargers at home and cottage. We have a 2020 Tesla Model 3 and a BMW i4 we bought last fall; the BMW is not as intuitive as the Tesla but at least it’s not built in the U.S. or China. I just spent a few grand on some repairs to the truck (cosmetic rust repair and new starter) and bought new winter and summer tires last year so I figure I can squeeze another few years out of it if there’s something interesting coming down the pipeline. I also thought that I could possibly switch to a smaller quarter-ton truck if there’s an electric one made in Canada. I was even looking at the Chrysler minivans with stow ‘n go seating – I thought I can keep it mostly configured as a cargo van with a sheet of plywood and buy my garden supplies in bags rather than bulk, although there isn’t an electric version, or even hybrid.
To sum up, an ideal vehicle would be a Canadian-built (or non-U.S., non-Chinese) electric vehicle that I can throw messy stuff into the back without worrying about getting the rear seats dirty. Minimum 3,500 pounds towing would be ideal. – Bruce
Mark Richardson:This is a tall order right now
Mark Richardson:This is a tall order right now. The electric pickup trucks that came onto the market in recent years are either very expensive or discontinued while the makers rethink the product. The all-electric Ford F-150 Lightning, for example, will be reintroduced as a plug-in hybrid, for the greater range buyers want.
Miranda Lightstone:Electric is one thing. Electric that can tow 3,500 pounds or more and still offer decent range is a whole other ball game. And I’m of the mindset that you don’t necessarily need a pickup to do all those workhorse things – an SUV will suffice.
Richardson:The only new half-ton electric pickups that fit Bruce’s criteria are the Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra EVs, as well as the gone-next-summer Tesla Cybertruck and the Riiscard them right now. The General Motors electric trucks are much less expensive, with the Silverado EV starting at around $70,000. All four of these trucks are made in the U.S., though, so that rules them out for Bruce
Lightstone:Bruce was curious about upcoming electric trucks
Lightstone:Bruce was curious about upcoming electric trucks as well. The Ram 1500 REV will be available in 2027, as will the all-new midsize fully electric Ford Fathom, and the revamped Ford F-150 Lightning PHEV. However, all of them will be built in the U.S., which again rules them out.

Richardson:The Ford Fathom is the really interesting one, because it’s designed to be affordable, starting around $40,000. It will be competition to the budget-priced Slate pickup truck, which will also be built in the U.S. and won’t be sold in Canada at all, owing to punitive tariffs.
Lightstone:That situation might change after the recent U.S. elections.
Richardson: Maybe. Who knows? If the two governments alter their stance on tariffs and the trade war softens, Bruce may be more amenable to buying an American-made truck. He should certainly keep on eye on them, just in case, but right now, there isn’t an electric truck of any size sold in Canada that’s not made in the United States.
Lightstone: Which leads me back to my original thought: SUV.
Richardson: Right. This is where the South Korean makers step up.
Lightstone: If Bruce wants large cargo space, high
Lightstone: If Bruce wants large cargo space, high range and towing ability, my brain goes straight to the South Korean-made, fully electric Kia EV9. It almost has pickup-like cargo space with approximately 2,320 litres with all the seats down.
Richardson: I hate to think of all those bags of mulch mucking up the cargo area, but Bruce can put down a mat or a tarp. The EV9 can certainly carry them easily. He can also install a dog mat, designed to protect car interiors from wet dogs and their hair and mud. It works just as well for garden supplies.
Lightstone:I regularly transport large bags of wood shavings and various farm animal feed in SUVs, and can attest that a good tarp is also just as effective at keeping the interior clean. It can also be substantially cheaper, and easier to remove should you want to put the seats back up in a pinch.
Richardson:I’m with you there
Richardson:I’m with you there. As well, if Bruce needs some supplies in bulk, he can pay for delivery. The extra cost each year is unlikely to come in above the cost of owning the truck.
Lightstone: It helps give the driver a made-in-Canada job, too.
Richardson: If Bruce opts for an SUV, there’s plenty of space in an EV9 with the seats flat – and they do fold flat. But if Bruce is serious about his cargo space, he might think about an electric cargo van. Kia makes the fairly compact PV5, which is a customizable van on the same chassis as the EV5 SUV.
Lightstone:Oh, I’ve heard about that one but haven’t driven it or even seen it in person. But you did, didn’t you?
Richardson:Yes, I drove one in South Korea
Richardson:Yes, I drove one in South Korea. It’s intended as a compact delivery van with seating for two, so it has the advantages of the minivan Bruce said he considered, but it’s not rated for towing anything at all. Any electric vehicle that can tow something will have a larger and stronger battery, and that adds to cost and weight.
Lightstone:Are there any electric delivery vans that can tow?
Richardson:No – it’s not what they’re intended for. Bruce did ask about anything coming down the pipeline, though, and Kia says it’s planning to bring a new mid-size, body-on-frame pickup truck to North America before the end of the decade. Hyundai will do the same thing, but the Kia is believed to be either a hybrid or a fully electric vehicle.
Lightstone: These are still just rumours, of course.
Richardson: Well, he did ask. But like I said at the start of this, an electric pickup truck that’s not American-built is a tall order to fill right now. Don’t forget, it’s really only Americans and Canadians who buy half-ton pickup trucks, after all. They’re very much a minority in almost every other international market.
Lightstone:I wish we had more station wagon options
Lightstone:I wish we had more station wagon options in North America. They are just as practical as SUVs, easier on gas and can tow, as well. But, alas, it’s a bit of a dirty word around here. As is minivan, but what about the made-in-Canada Chrysler Pacifica PHEV?
Richardson:Bruce won’t find a new one – it was discontinued last year, owing to slow sales. The PHEV did not offer stow ’n go seats that fold both rear rows flat under the floor, because that space was taken up by the larger battery. Those fold-away seats would have been much of the appeal.
Lightstone:We’re running out of options here.
Richardson:Frankly, I think he’s best to look for a used Ford F-150 Lightning or Chevrolet Silverado EV, so he can rest assured he’s not giving most of his money to America, and he’s buying it from its Canadian owner. Either that, or keep the Ram another few years to see how our relationship changes south of the border.
Lightstone:I’m not totally against a used truck,
Lightstone:I’m not totally against a used truck, but I’m not convinced Bruce needsa pickup. I really think he should give the EV9 a good once over and test-drive. It checks all his necessary boxes, save for having a flatbed for bulk supplies.
Richardson:If not the Kia EV9, then the Hyundai Ioniq 9, which is essentially the same vehicle. Both will give him the size and towing power he’s looking for, if he doesn’t mind spreading a tarpaulin in the back to keep all that bagged mulch out of his seats. Better yet, keep the Ram for a bit longer and check back in two years.
What car should you buy? Write to Mark and Miranda atglobedrive@globeandmail.comand use ‘What car’ as part of your subject line. E-mails with different subject lines may not be answered.
Shopping for a new car? Check out the newGlobe Drive Build and PriceTool to see the latest discounts, rebates and rates on new cars, trucks and SUVs.Click hereto get your price.
